
Photo by Eric
Isn’t the stock market gambling?
When I hear this question, occasionally I am tempted to respond ‘what is gambling’?
This isn’t just a flippant response—it is that—but it is also useful for clarification.
One definition of gambling is the attempt to win against overwhelming odds, essentially hoping that you’ll receive an over-sized pay-out.
Of course, gambling comes in a variety of forms from the impossible-to-win lotto to a night of poker with friends where you might just be the best player who will consistently win.
In a similar way, one can choose to gamble in the stock market (angling for oversized returns) or to make logical investments that will most likely pay off over time.
Many factors affect one’s ability to make money in the stock market (purchase price, dividends, etc) but the fundamental difference remains—stock is concrete ownership in a public company. While a purchased lotto ticket will soon become worthless and a night of poker can go horribly wrong despite your skill, purchased stock will retain some value as long as the company remains in business.
What about the risk of the company going out of business? Tomorrow we’ll answer that question and discuss one possible solution—index funds.





Kyle added:
January 17th, 2008
Interesting question. I agree with your premise. If you are a day trader type then you are a gambler to the core. But if you put money in the stock market in hope of long term gain then you are an investor and not so much a gambler. Although it all appears to be a gamble right now….
Aaron Stroud added:
January 17th, 2008
Thanks for the comment Kyle. Last night I came across this instructive quote by Larry Swedroe:
“Yes active investing is exciting. Investing, however, was never meant to be exciting. Wall Street and the media created that myth. Instead, it is meant to be about providing you with the greatest odds of achieving your financial goals with the least amount of risk. That is what differentiates investing from speculating (gambling).”
Kyle added:
January 30th, 2008
Great quote. Definitely words to invest by.